This post was in the works for a while, but it ultimately ended up after all of the main reviews as the penultimate entry in this series! These are just pretty quick looks at custom ideas I had.
My first piece here is a look at a Hatter I didn't select, and how it might have been a contender for this series in different circumstances.
So...working with Effanbee made me want to give their Hatter a chance after all, but not as an official contender. I was curious to see if there was a possibility of head-swapping the doll with a better character face or else just seeing if the doll was okay on his own. The actual head was just the generic one used at the time, and far too bland.
Nothing about the box that I haven't shown prior. My copy is partially undone inside the box and perhaps in worse condition than I expected. I might have picked the unboxed copy which looked better-aged.
![]() |
| His eyes are wonky because the hairnet is holding one closed. |
Here he is put together.
Part of my interest in this doll came from the fact that the outfit looked to be pretty darn accurate to the artwork. Of course, the hat has the famous label, but another detail very true to Tenniel which other dolls don't seem to catch is the way the coat works--as you can see in the art, the jacket is only closed at the neck, not anywhere below, and Effanbee's doll matches that. The patterning of the trousers underneath, which seem to cover the whole torso, also looks proper.
The Effanbee hat is grey felt which is glued together, and the glue has gone brown and disintegrated, leaving the hat less tidy than it should be, with the top and the layers of the brim separating. The label is present and the writing looks like a decent freehand copy of the text directly as drawn by Tenniel.
The doll has slightly curly brown waves, but the top has some obvious thin bald spots.
The face is uninteresting. It's just the same basic childlike mold Effanbee used at this time and delivers nothing of the Hatter as I know him. This tanks an otherwise pretty scrupulous and spot-on visual adaptation, and with the context of the Effanbee Queen of Hearts in the same collection, this doll not being caricatured feels unfair.
As mentioned, the coat and pants are cut pretty precisely like Tenniel drew them. This is my second red felt Hatter coat after my first example, the Storyland doll by Madame Alexander.
The Effanbee coat has four gold button decorations on the breasts and two more pairs of buttons on the sleeves, which are also lace-trimmed, and one last pair on the back of the coat.
The starched collar and huge bow are accurately included as part of the coat's sew, with the bow being pale yellow and dotted to match the artwork. The collar opens with a snap. Underneath, the Hatter's checked pants are an unusual piece sewn kind of like overalls/dungarees, riding up to his collar with elastic straps. I've never seen a piece quite like this before.
The Hatter has sheer socks under his trouser legs, but somehow, and unfortunately, these were stuck to the doll stand leg braces, and the socks tore and got ruined when trying to pull the doll out. The shoes are pleather pieces and the saddle design looks alright, but the laces look off for a Victorian look.
I like what this doll does, but the face is not interesting or accurate.
So. Was there an Effanbee doll head which looked like Tenniel's Mad Hatter? Well, maybe. I wasn't sure if the head and body would be compatible because it came from a larger doll model, but an oversized head would of course be a visual benefit if the pieces could fit or be rigged together. And where did I find the most Hatterish Effanbee face sculpt?
...my deepest apologies to former First Lady Eleanor Roosevelt. She was a truly great woman and does not deserve this, but out of context, in a vacuum...the likeness is transferrable.
This is a "Great Moments in History" Effanbee doll from 1985, occupying a slightly larger doll scale which I believe was shared by the celebrity "Effanbee Legends" dolls. The box is old and musty-looking, and features a removable perforated panel over the doll window.
Here's the window unpeeled. Mrs. Roosevelt is not fully secured, and the twist wires were exposed on the back, so I'm not sure if there was another layer or panel to this box that is now missing.
Here she is unboxed. One of her applied shoe buckles has fallen off and she doesn't stand properly on her own thanks to uneven legs and her feet not being sloped to match her heels, so I popped her into the Hatter's stand to take these pictures.
The First Lady was a perfectly lovely woman in life, but she's sporting a detailed grinning head sculpt that is a little disconcerting and unflattering in doll form, but pretty darn perfect for a Hatter, all things considered. She's got the teeth, and and her hairstyle is gender-neutral. I just needed to see if the head could swap bodies and wear the Hatter hat.
Mrs. Roosevelt's hat is a pillbox style that matches her maroon dress. It's slightly elastic with a ribbed/corrugated fabric texture, but it in no way grips onto her head. It can't be securely displayed on her.
Her hair is part of the head mold and is painted shades of grey. There is no hair bun, so this could easily work for a male doll. I don't think I've seen a doll with molded hair that covered part of their ears like this before.
The face is a bit tilted to one side, and shows a lot of tooth in a way that doesn't look super warm and charming the way it would in motion on a real woman. The profile feels pretty darn solid for capturing the Hatter, though. The eyes are realistically sized and are molded and painted, not inset or moving sleepy eyes.
Around her neck, the doll has a pearl string held closed simply by twisting the two end beads around each other. This is great. I needed a fifth pearl string for my Haunted Mansion Bride doll who somehow forgot how many strands Constance wears, and the necklace being easy to twist on and off makes it a non-invasive non-frustrating addition to that doll.
Mrs. Roosevelt is wearing a matched jacket and dress that also pair with the hat. The jacket has white lapels with a gold fleur-de-lis pin held on by folded metal tabs on the back of the lapel, and it has white cuffs.
The dress underneath is sleeveless and not shaped to the bust, but it looks really chic. The belt is removable with a snap, and the dress has two snaps in back.
Under the dress, she wears a white petticoat skirt over white underwear and sheer stockings.
The shoes are simple black pumps, with metal buckles glued on--one fell off sometime since her release. The feet are not angled to let the heels stand her up.
The female body of this scale is more maturely sculpted than Effanbee's smaller dolls, but no more articulated.
The Hatter head comes from an era of Effanbee where the necks were pegs projecting from the torso into hollows in the head pieces (which include the exterior neck). Eleanor Roosevelt has a head that plugs down into the torso, so there's no direct compatibility. The neck on Eleanor is also pretty long for the Hatter. I cut the vinyl of both pieces, creating a large cavity in the top of the Hatter torso and shortening the Roosevelt neck until I could shove the pieces together. It's not a stable play-worthy connection, but it stays in place well enough.
I wiped off Eleanor's makeup details and sewed the layers of the Hatter hat brim together while trying to regluing the top piece, but the glue created a white crust that seeped through the fabric. I tried repainting the Eleanor hair brown because without aggressively cutting down the molded hair and opening holes in the head that would need patching, there wasn't a way to do yarn hair in the more authentic shape. And I wasn't in the mood to try all that. Here's the result.
With the elements of facial likeness and the scrupulous costuming, this is a very close adaptation, but the hair silhouette does make a difference. Either it's not close enough, or it's too close, because I'm not lit up by this result. Silver Label still takes it for me. I think a dynamically-jointed doll body and an Eleanor head with rooted hair I could have replaced would make all the difference and turn this into a serious competitor with the official picks, but he's just not there.
Here he is alongside the Effanbee official Queen of Hearts and the custom hybrid Alice I felt paired well with her.
The hybrid Hatter works well with Alice in a different way from the Queen. Each is fine with Alice but they're clearly different visual styles from each other.
My next piece was inspired by another Hatter I didn't select, and who I didn't want to revise, either.
See, there's a Liv doll from the "Liv in Wonderland" series, where Liv character Katie dresses as the Hatter.
This doll has merit. She has her own take on stacked teacups as an accessory, and if she's like any other Liv doll, her hair is an interchangeable wig with a molded plastic pixie cut suitable for display under the cap, which is a feature of the Liv dolls I've always admired. Perhaps a funkier wig, or the molded short-hair look, would endear her to me, but her visual aesthetic is neither old-fashioned nor wacky nor distinct enough for her to catch my eye.
But what about...well, "Liv 2.0" is a drastically generous way to describe it, for myriad reasons. This isn't the same company, nor is it an upgrade. But what about Liv's...freaky little imitator?
The #SnapStar dolls by Yulu were objectively embarrassing and not very good. They were bizarrely-proportioned small dolls attempting to cash in on social media photo trends while reusing/stealing the head style and wig gimmicks of the bygone Liv line. They looked cheap and weird and are inferior to Liv and incohesive as attempts at a chibi fashion doll. I've always been oddly fascinated by them, however, and Dawn, with her menswear influence and simple black and white color palette, seemed like she could make a fun custom Hatter. She's got the oversized head and collar, and the Liv wig/sculpted hair mechanic I was always interested in, and I did want to explore a Black character in the Hatter role. Dawn was exceptionally cheap and accessible new on the aftermarket; these dolls never lit up anybody's world.
Dawn, of the SnapStars group, is the modernist chic city girl...in theory. I like her fashion aesthetic the most of the SnapStars. The character art is lovely...
The doll in the box is an extremely poor match.
The words "uncanny" and "soulless" spring to mind, and you never want that from a doll. I'd love the dolls if they captured the artwork, but the product is quite off-putting. I'm not surprised these dolls performed poorly.
The SnapStar box is...oddly nice? It's a four-sided sleeve lid over a tray with the pieces resting flush, almost like a smartphone's box, and that seems deliberate with the phone-shaped window. The box seems designed for repacking and storage if you want that, which is laudable.
The deluxe experience is a bit lessened by the view of nasty-looking glue visible through the back of the window panel. I would have expected the budget went into the box more than the doll, but this glue is ugly. Maybe not.
Dawn is in a plastic tray and secured by only one plastic tie around her neck. This was so tight and impossible to cut that I actually cut into the plastic to widen the hole and shove one end of the tag through to the front so it no longer held down the neck.
I've heard of other SnapStars having a neck clip in their plastic tray which they snapped into, like the waist grips of Monster High stands, but this copy had a plastic tie with no evidence of a clip rigging being possible for the doll tray.
The phone accessory is just tucked into a fitted compartment.
Under the doll tray are the green screen and doll stand, both the same chroma-key color so both can be edited out of photos.
The green screen unfolds and has tabs that tuck in to make a more 3D stage, though the creases hinder the uniform look that makes editing it out easier.
The doll stands are based on action figure or mini BJD stands, with a multi-jointed arm that allows the doll to be posed with no contact to the base should you prefer that, with the peg at the end of the arm allowing the doll to spin on the axis for non-upright poses as well.
I love that the joints of the stand have hubs designed to be gripped and turned by fingers to tighten or loosen them. I've experienced a stand like this where you need to get out a screwdriver to re-tighten the joints every time the arm moves, but this is very user-friendly. I haven't seen other reviewers remark on this functionality.
I honestly wish this stand wasn't part of the green-screen gimmick because it'd be a very attractive and useful stand in black.
The stand has a little peg at the end of the arm which plugs into the nape of the doll's neck--a clever placement since the costumes can still cover the dolls' backs, though it's a bit tricky to tuck the arm in with the shirt collar in place. I'm impressed with how sturdy this stand is, though. At no point did the doll's weight cause the joints to move or force me to tighten them with the turning hubs, and she can even rotate on the peg in her neck without her weight spinning her back to an upright pose. I'd give the box an 8.5 and the doll stand a 10. Such a shame the doll is hovering around a 4 or 5.
The doll design doesn't sparkle. The oversized semi-realistic heads aren't flattering, and don't have much personality.
Dawn's wig is dark brown and curly. The fiber feels okay, though I wish the hair was a bit flatter on top so the curls hung down rather that rising up above her dome.
The wig cap has a peg in the center that goes into a hole on the back of the head. The wig can spin, which is kind of nice if you want to have the parting offset rather than centered. The peg could stand to have a bit more friction.
Under the wig, Dawn has sculpted and painted black hair with some slight wave texture.
It could have been nice to see a tighter hair texture molded on Dawn. While the dolls aren't meant to be literally wearing wigs or weaves, it is a bit unusual to see a Black doll with relatively straight hair under a curly hairpiece. Dawn's head mold is unique, though, and does have wavier pixie hair than the others, so an effort was made.
Dawn's face shows pretty clear influence from Liv, though the head is a different mold. The lips look simplified and more Bratz-like (a trait shared by the whole line), while the inset eyes are not stellar.
Dawn's lip paint doesn't fill the exaggerated lip sculpt, and I don't think the purple color is flattering. Her costume wants black and white makeup to match, and a black lip would look great. The pink blush and eyeshadow (which look redder in the photos) also don't impress me. I do like that her eyes are brown, but the detail/clarity isn't great. They're glittery, but it just makes the irises look blurred.
Dawn has simple black earrings which are slightly Art Deco, seen above. They're totally lost in her hair when the wig is on.
The costume is an abject failure to replicate the artwork, but is pretty suitable for a city Hatter. This isn't the lovely cape with sleeves in the drawing, and the costume is all cheap satin with no drape and no hope of wearing with the sleeves empty.
Under the jacket, which is what it is on the doll, the blouse and shorts and unusual tie are all one piece.
![]() |
| Sorry for the poor exposure; the phone defaulted to overexposed and lightened the doll's skintone otherwise. |
I'm impressed by the presence of full sleeves, and the coat doesn't get in the way. The doll's hands can pop out if you really pull, which makes dressing easier. The white sleeve cuffs have a lot of stray threads.
Dawn has nice heeled boots. I was worried her jointed feet would break when I pulled them off.
The purse is a solid lump, but looks good.
The smartphone accessory is a cute idea, and I like the clip handle on the back that her fingers can slide into, but the glue for the screen decal is the goopy, sticky, never-cures type that some unfortunate dolls are saddled with for certain pieces, so the screen just slides off the plastic phone in a gooey stringy trail.
![]() |
| This would be nice if the screen stayed on. |
Dawn is a little doll with what should be a bigger doll's head, which is why she suits a Hatter retheming so well.
![]() |
| Monster High heads are oversized, but not to the point of feeling stolen from a larger body. |
I don't like chibi art, but I do see a bizarre surrealist appeal to more realistic oversize heads which are more extremely exaggerated. I can understand a Blythe or Pullip doll quite easily; I see the Alice of it, of course, but there's also something of faerie to a giant-headed small person that such dolls resemble. My acceptance typically only goes as far as treating a big-headed doll as an objectively strange fantasy being, though.
Dawn has a healthy set of joints. She has wrists, which the Barbie Silver Label Hatter doll lacks, but most of her other joints perform less than the Hatter's own. Her static ball-knob head joint barely lets the head tip forward and back at all, and her bust only swivels with no tipping. Her elbows also flex further at one point of their rotation than others, and her knees aren't stopped from the "bird-legs" visual of bending too far forward. I was surprised by the ankle joints, but I wish the feet had flat soles, since they're not fully flat even at the "flat-footed" hinge angle.
She achieves some good dynamic displays that synergize with the doll stand. The photo-taking gimmick isn't a letdown--your model can be set up a lot of ways. The app functionality for this doll line is long defunct, though.
To begin restyling the doll, I selected some round black Barbie Extra Minis shades and a Mego top hat to mount on a headband. I also found that L.O.L. Tween Max Wonder's "Curiouser and Curiouser" sneakers were a good fit, so they had to be used. The repainted watch purse I previously gave to Rochelle Goyle was also a natural fit.
As you can see, I also felt like Dawn needed larger hands to balance the caricature of her head. I found that G1 Monster High boy hands were a good physical fit in her wrist sockets, though the only pair I had to spare were too valuable--sourced from Maul Monsteristas Billy dolls (the one I owned and one I didn't--a spare forearm I ordered alone before getting the full doll). I ordered a pair of G1 Deuce forearms and hands with plans to dye the hands stark black as gloves, but kept the Billy hands in for testing the look.
I felt like I was onto something. I removed the blush and original lip paint, and applied gloss to the shades and the clock purse to polish them up a bit. I took off the gold paint on the Max Wonder shoe buckles, and repainted the "Curiouser" bands black. I repainted the doll's face and hair a bit, giving her white streaks on her pixie hair and heavy white eyeshadow. I then learned I had to keep her expression calm and cool to hit the right vibe. I tried her with a grinning strip of white between her lips, and all looked good with the pixie cut I was staring at during the whole repaint, but the moment I popped the wig back on, I was unsettled and dismayed to perceive echoes of minstrel caricature.
Maybe you don't see it, but the connotation was unavoidable for me, created by the innocent design elements all coalescing in just the wrong way. Of course I absolutely didn't want that connotation, so I repainted the mouth a second time with a stylized retro-dolly closed lip shape. That restored the artsy vibe I went into this doll for, anyhow, and the result looked less awkward besides. The grinning look was also off-mission for my driving idea anyway, even if all of the design factors together had played innocently with that facial expression. I found her vibe first with the closed factory lip paint.
It's not fair that this character didn't feel perfectly innocent while wearing these clothes and hair and a wide grin all at once...but history is not fair. Harmful iconography leaves a mark on any imagery that resembles it in the future. For the same reasons, I'd never put a flag with the spiritual manji symbol on my house because nobody would ever see good intentions there. That's unfair too, but that's how it is. And that's not to say this stoic Hatter is out of character, that she's not "mad". She might just deliver the kind of nonsense that comes from those who see themselves as revolutionary artists. She walks and talks like an influential fashion designer or health guru and attributes everything to far grander purpose and meaning than it could ever possibly have. She quotes gibberish as if it's thought-provoking and insightful. That could be her flavor of "madness". All she believes and holds as immense conceptual truth is only as deep as her cup of tea.
I got my Deuce Gorgon hands and dyed them stark black as gloves. Then I got to building this Hatter a little table. I went minimalist and pretentious to suit her aesthetic, taking the clock-as-table motif from the steampunk Hatter and adapted it to an artsy sundial here!
I didn't even think of it at first, but the sundial table doubles as a reference to the poem Jabberwocky. In the opening stanza, it's stated that the slithy toves did gyre and gimble in the wabe. When Alice puzzles over the poem with Humpty Dumpty, he explains that toves are a creature like badgers and corkscrews mixed together, and that gyre and gimble are actions of prancing and running circles, while the wabe is the area around a sundial where the toves live, as there's a "way before it" and a "way behind it".
I was fully willing to build another hybrid Alice to pair with this Hatter, in the same style as the one I built for Silver Label, but I couldn't find a mini body to match with the head I would have have picked as this Hatter's scene partner.
I really like my SnapStar Hatter, but she wasn't easy to photograph the way I wanted. Modernist black-and-white contrast is hard to light and set up, and paired with the injustice of the camera hating her skintone, I wasn't sure I was getting the visuals I really wanted. I hope I was able to convey the appeal even a little bit. I think the oversized head paired with the Monster High boy hands made for really enjoyable surreal proportions, and the chic quirky avant-garde metropolitan modernist angle was really fun to adapt this character design to and lent itself to interesting ideas about how the role would be re-characterized in that framing. A fashion/costume designer calling herself an artiste could be infuriating to spend time with, and could be just as much a fount of baffling rhetoric as a Victorian milliner poisoned by mercury. Of all three of my custom Hatters (and even my custom Alice), the SnapStar is also the most functional modification in terms of handling. Her hybridization with the hands made for the securest fit of foreign doll parts in this group! Alongside Alice, she's also one of my favorite visual results, perhaps because, in the SnapStar's case, she places the Hatter idea in a compellingly different aesthetic from Tenniel rather than trying to imitate his art very closely.
![]() |
| All three of my custom Hatters. |
The only real issue with the Hatter once known as Dawn is that her hat doesn't have any functionality with her no-wig look. The headband I designed isn't graceful or wearable as such on the pixie hair and an elastic band wouldn't be very friendly to the wig. I could maybe devise a separate adapter to insert into the hat that would pop into the wig hole on the base head, but that might not look right in terms of placement. Hm.
SnapStar dolls do have a niche--playing big-headed fantasy weirdos. I think Echo could be a lovely strange little fairy doll with her odd proportions and fantasy hair. But I personally think you have to take them to a weird place to make them shine. I love this doll design as an oddball, but its original purpose wasn't hitting right. The oversized hands also made her stylization feel more complete, cohesive, and confident.
That's it for this interlude! These dolls are not contenders for the finale, but they'll have their spots to be discussed. Expect the finale very soon! I've got to then rush out some photos to finish my Haunted Mansion series and get it out before December!



















































































No comments:
Post a Comment