Monday, November 16, 2026

Hatter Madness 6, or "Tears for Gears": The Madame Alexander "Steam Punk" Hatter!


This little sadboy is responsible for a project extension. 

So, when I was reviewing my first Hatter selection back on the other end of this year, from Madame Alexander's Storyland Collection, I peeked at the other Hatters the brand had produced to provide a better overview of what I hadn't chosen to discuss. But typing "madame alexander mad hattter doll" into eBay served me up a huge surprise--a not-childlike fashion doll in a steampunk theme and red lipstick with streaky eye makeup...

I was doomed. He is paiiinfullly 2014, and I love deliciously dated dolls. And an emo steampunk pretty-boy Hatter doll I'd never heard of, from a brand I'd least expect to produce one? Yeah, I needed to investigate. He fit my loose "Hatters of the year" concept as well by suiting an autumnal November vibe. And he made a better final main review than the drastically spooky LDD entry before, as well as evening the gender balance of my picks and bringing this all full-circle. I found my last Hatter through my first, and both are from the same company while being so different each earns a review.

Close to the time set for the review, I found a complete copy in good condition. I was very surprised to see a message from the seller, on the day I was to receive my doll, stating that he was bringing along a "little Madame Alexander friend" to keep him company on the journey! Was I getting a freebie surprise doll? An ornament in the likeness of their dolls? Those exist. I just hoped it wasn't the Wendy model of the Hatter that I already had.

Here's the display ready for review. I threw this together on the day I was getting the doll, without pre-buying any steampunk props. I couldn't wait and so I made do with what I had. This doll was my "autumn vibes" Hatter too, so I emphasized leaves and pumpkins in the treats.


The box is printed differently, but very much akin to the nineties Storyland box I reviewed at the start of this project. The Steampunk doll's box is the same basic "shoebox" build with an opaque lid, and has a generic print used for many dolls and labeling only on one foot of the box.

Box stood upright, lid's top facing camera.


With the lid off, the box has pink tissue folded over from both sides, and the certificate of authenticity which claims this doll to be #95 out of an edition of 300. Madame Alexander separating "steampunk" into two words kind of betrays that they're not really "in" on it. It feels a bit like a grandma texting her Gen Alpha grandson about "that Fort Night game you love so much".


Lifting the tissue reveals the doll. In the style of Madame and Effanbee dolls alike, he has a wrist tag suitable for identification and display when out of box.


The Hatter is secured in the box with beautiful simplicity--he's merely tied down by two white ribbons--one around his waist and one around his ankles, which are threaded through the backdrop and tied in bows. Strips of pink tissue are laid between the doll and the ribbons.



The hat is packaged separately in a plastic bag taped to the side. 

I didn't keep my Storyland Hatter's box, but I might keep this one. I imagine both Alexander Hatters could fit inside it.

Here's the doll unboxed. He has no doll stand, but doesn't really need one. The only challenge was standing him on a cloth surface as I did here. He has no accessories to hold, so he won't be contributing to the tea party.


This doll feels more like an alternate-universe version of the Carroll character, or maybe the makeup is giving me edgy 2010s fanfic vibes, but I can't just call this doll the Hatter. He needs his own character name...I think "Mercury" is the obvious choice. Mercury Missingtime? 

I think this doll is a confluence of 2010s aesthetic trends and also some fallout from the Tim Burton Alice in Wonderland film. A redheaded Hatter with makeup seems like a potential loose adaptation or cash-in for the version played by Johnny Depp (a visual design I still love despite myself), though the steampunk doll is relatively "safe". His makeup feels like a mix of modern emo and silent-movie or Italian theatrical styling, but he's not outright goth and even describing him as emo is a little bit of a stretch given the makeup is the only thing with those tones. I think this is more likely to be a product of the Madame Alexander designers categorically not being very alternative, so this is probably poser art for both steampunk and edgy sensibilities. I don't care.

The tag around the Mercury's wrist has the same branding design as the Steampunk Oz dolls which purportedly released the same year. The Hatter not sharing a doll scale with them and having no Wonderland companions makes this association feel pretty strange. This tag here also claims that the Hatter was an even smaller edition of 250 pieces, so I don't know what to trust. Is the certificate or the tag correct?



Steampunk Dorothy's box.

Attractionistas Maddie is officially my largest/tallest Hatter selection, as Mercury is smaller than a Ken, standing at 10". I'd have enjoyed if he was a scale above 1/6, but he wouldn't fit with the others very well if so.

The hat here is somewhat modest, being perhaps more tall and pinched in its exaggeration than wide and big. It's got a great natural plaid color pattern for its fabric, trimmed with an orange velvet ribbon, and my autumnal read of the doll is validated by a silver leaf charm sewn among some tiny metal gear decorations!



This is the second of only two main Hatter contenders in my project to have the famous price label on the side of the hat. Mercury's is sewn in such a way that it's not tucked into the hat band. It can be tucked under the band, but there's so little overlap between them that it's hard to actually get the card fully tucked, and if you do so, it presses the bottom down in such a way that the top of the card bends out away from the hat and it becomes hard to see and read. Untucked, it sits against the hat as it should.

I'd have liked this hat a lot more if it fit Mercury even a little. The diameter is just not large enough for his crown, and no amount of trying to pull it down resulted in a secure fit. It's perched on top of the head like this because it had to be. Come on, guys. The thing the character is named for, and he can't even wear it? This had the perfect setup to be one of the best hats in the bunch, alongside Sybil's, but it ended up like Disney Maddie's instead--incompetently made.

Like the Storyland Hatter's piece when I got it, the inner rim of the hat is also poking out and down, spoiling the look further.


Some of the velvet band looks worn.


Mercury's hair is a coppery red shade and it's wavy and sits above the shoulder. It's perhaps a bit more of a billowy or foppish silhouette than I want for the doll. His promo photo, which was evidently a prototype with a few minor differences, showed a less voluminous hairstyle that contrasted the nontraditional makeup in a way I liked. 


When I later tried to see the sculpt of the ears and realized I couldn't uncover them, I realized this hair is attached to a wig glued over the head.


Mercury's face is the core of the doll's appeal. I'd have skipped him otherwise. 


For one, the makeup must be addressed. He's got red lipstick, grey eyeshadow up to his brows, and teary trails of eye makeup, which feels very much an attempt to evoke 2000s-2010s alternative moody artsy makeup, and I don't know why this was the choice and I love it. I don't associate steampunk with emo any further than both being niche subcultures popular on old Tumblr, but it's really fun. Honestly, with the makeup and hat, I can't help but wonder if the designer(s) were familiar with Panic! At the Disco and "I Write Sins Not Tragedies" or if, like, a daughter was a fan of them and the designer parent was aware through that.


The other thing unusual about the doll is that he has sleepy eyes! I kind of expected a single-piece cast vinyl head with painted eyes before I got a better look at his pictures, and that made him quite unusual. I'm used to sleepy eyes on baby-doll faces, and they work on childlike Effanbee pieces, but they're far less expected on dolls proportioned like they're past childhood. Part of me hoped maybe the eyes would have friction and could be adjusted by hand in the open/closed spectrum like the Mme. A Wendy models (seen in the first Hatter review), but I was prepared for these to be weighted eyes, and they are.


I'm honestly beginning to think that Alexander's Wendy dolls are meant to have weighted eyes. Maybe my Storyland Hatter wasn't supposed to have the friction making his eyes work like a switch. I need to increase my sample size on dolls from the period of my Storyland doll. I wouldn't be surprised if more recent Wendys have normal weighted eyes, but did they always? If my Hatter was an error with overly tight eyeballs, I consider it a feature rather than a bug, but if the Wendy dolls, at least of his period, deliberately had controllable eye openness, then I applaud the choice.

Mercury's face looks good, but there's also something eerie about it. Something about the simplicity of the head and the bright lips, shaped more by paint than the sculpt, gives him a blank haunted-doll vibe, like a porcelain antique jester or something, if that makes any sense. I like this doll, but he has potential to look uncanny, too.

The outfit of this doll is pretty fancy, and is giving the Silver Label Hatter doll a challenge.


The outfit begins with a jacket that has a rounded single-lobed label, which might sit wider than it deserves to. The body of the jacket is a very shiny checkerboard of dark grey and black, while the lapel is olive-colored and the stitching is red. The sleeves could also stand to be slightly shorter.


The jacket has tails, but they sit in an overlap the way they're sewn. They're not separated. 



I like the look of the piece, but the Silver Label jacket feels better-tailored on its wearer.



Under the jacket, Mercury is sleeveless. Not a surprise.



Mercury's waistcoat is alternating panels of blue and teal and has more metal gears sewn to the lapel on his right.


Surprisingly, the only concrete clock imagery on this doll is a charm sewn to the left breast, depicting a pocket watch. I assume the clock face is an applied decal. I wasn't going to test it and damage the look!


The waistcoat is a separate layer, opening with a hook that goes through a loop of thread.


Here he is without the waistcoat.


And the waistcoat removed, better showing off the color alternation.


With the jacket and hat and waistcoat off, everything except the boots is one costume piece. The shirt, tie, belt, and shiny pinstripe pants are all sewn together and open down the back with snaps.


The collar can be folded up like the Tenniel book illustrations, but is designed to be turned down, and doesn't look as good standing upright. The bowtie is a good complement to the vest. The belt is a red leather element.


The boots are also leathery elements with some intimidating-looking buckles and straps, but the actual closure is simple and easy-to-use zippers down the back.




The boots encircle the bottoms of the trouser legs, but there's nothing keeping them tight and pulled down inside the boots, so they're easy to get messy.

The Silver Label costume broke down differently, with the shirt and waistcoat being one piece separate from the trousers. The Steampunk doll is more lavish in places and feels a tad more polished, like how the waistcoat's back is just as attractive as the front, but the tailoring is worse. Silver Label's hat fits his crown and his jacket is perfectly sewn for his body, while Mercury's costume feels awkward and less functional in some ways.

I was curious about Mercury's body type and articulation, because Madame Alexander, though having done plenty of dolls, isn't best known for fashion dolls...and one of their least categories of doll design is "man". Like, this was the first post-childhood male doll sculpt from Mme. A that I was ever consciously aware of. As such, I had no idea what physique to expect. Would he borrow from action figures and be ridiculously toned like too many modern male dolls? Would he be slighter more like a vintage Ken? And how would he be jointed? Fashion dolls don't typically have the sleepy eyes, so I was tempering my expectations for something more on the level of simple Barbie or Effanbee.

The actual body design is a bit odd, but I suppose that fits the head. The age of the figure isn't super defined, and the torso is lightly toned, but skinny while the arms are quite thick and the neck is short and thick with the oversized head.



This is the most jointed Madame Alexander doll I've encountered, but he's below the standard of Monster High.

The neck has ball-jointed motion quite similar to the Silver Label doll's, looking further back than forward but having good range.




The shoulders and elbows are rotating hinges which fall slightly below the range of comparable MH joints, and the wrists are not jointed. The latter aspect is also pretty similar to the Silver Label doll!


The waist has a simple swivel joint above the navel, but the pieces aren't designed to look good when rotated out of a frontward alignment.


The torso only twists 180 degrees, getting stopped at both sides before it can turn fully backward.

The legs are the most baffling. While the hips look like normal rotating hinges, the rotation is strictly diagonal, and turning the hips forward is to turn them outward. The legs are not capable of swinging directly forward and this standard sitting shape is impossible for the doll:


Mercury is capable of dynamic standing poses, but typical sitting, splits, or kneeling are all off the table. This is the most normal seated pose he can achieve. The joints pop into place with the legs raised up and rotated inward with the way the hips are built. When sitting with his legs straight out, his knees turn his feet to the side:

Photo taken later.

Bending his knees results in this:


It looks like he should be sitting on a tuffet rather than an armchair. This can't even be finessed into the more familiar sitting pose by rotating the knees, because the knee pegs and sockets have a keyhole connection stopping the pegs from turning! I discovered this when trying to turn the left knee and finding it to harmlessly pop out.


I don't expect this odd hip articulation from a fashion doll. It's also not caused by the cut of the hip sockets. On dolls like LDD, it makes sense why the legs splay out when turned because that's just how their pieces fit together.


Mercury's body is cut in such a way that his hips should swing straight forward. I think they don't because the actual rotation pegs are mounted diagonally upward inside his torso. In this next image, the dotted light green lines are how a typical hip rotation would be mounted, horizontally, and the black lines illustrate the way I think the doll's hip rotation pegs are actually angled inside the torso.


Mercury has no ankle joints.

While he may have lost a point to Silver Label with the torso joint just being a swivel, he is slaughtered by the Silver Label doll from the legs down. Silver Label's "athletic Stacie" articulation is overall superior, with the dynamic torso ball joint and much better legs making a big difference, despite him sharing Mercury's limitations of no wrists or knee rotation.



I've said it, and I'll repeat it: it was extremely unfair for a doll that good to be so early in this project!

I think Mercury's body is an interesting one, for sure, and has given me the best experience of the Madame dolls I've reviewed so far. I don't like the unreliable nature of elastic stringing, and Mercury's joints perform well for what they are.

Mercury's tea tableau got some photos to try to find my cover shot.




I wasn't fully feeling his character until I gave him a haircut, though. The result is messy, but it improved his silhouette. I picked the moodiest color grade for his cover shot.



By the way, the friend he came with was a Happy Meal toy of the Wicked Witch of the East. Madame Alexander x McDonald's is a weird little niche!


The Wicked Witch of the East has always been a fascinating character to merchandise in sets based on the 1939 Wizard of Oz, because her only canonical/textual character design feature is her striped black and white tights and her ruby slippers-this is literally all that's ever seen of her:


It's fascinating to see how doll companies have extrapolated to complete this mostly-unseen character's design. Madame has done it a few times, and Barbie has as well. The Witch of the East is universally depicted as human-colored unlike her green sister, and this one is blonde with a red corset and hat, plum skirt, and green belt.




These Happy Meal dolls are very simple, with mostly molded clothing and five basic swivel joints. The hat is not removable. These little dolls do have working tiny weighted sleepy eyes, though. They're taller than LDD Mini dolls.

Three scales of Madame Alexander.

The two Hatters couldn't feel more different!


To fix Mercury's hat, I shoved this wire piece inside to grip the sides of his head a little. I also attempted to iron the brim flat, but burned the velvet a little--fortunately, the leaf charm can swing over to cover it. I also flattened the inner edge of the hat hole.

This slid up the hat, with the pieces on the bottom providing support on the sides of the head.

I also did some more research to put Mercury's build into context. I've encountered similar articulation on Madame's contemporary Travel Friends doll body, which I got through an Alice design, but the head didn't tip and the waist didn't swivel. 

Travel Friends Alice--approximately 7", I believe?

The hips probably moved more directly forward and back. 

When I searched for dolls of the 2010s era to identify who else would have used Mercury's molds, I learned a lot. 

For starters, quite excitingly, I found out that Wendy-model dolls began to include the same kind of mid-limb articulation (if not at the shoulders and hips too), and that's dangerous. Like, had I known that their delightfully grumpy Peter Peter Pumpkin Eater of the time almost certainly had higher articulation than the 1990s Wendy Hatter I picked, I'd have got him in before this past Halloween!

The dirty marks on this eBay copy's face are actual dirt, not design.

I also found some previous users of Mercury's sculpts. The first I identified was a licensed Oscar Diggs from Oz: The Great and Powerful, wearing his stage-magic costume from the start of the film. Without the robe and turban, he could pass for his more typical look, but he'd be missing a top hat.


Even better, before Oscar...was Gomez Addams. He might have originated this body.

I think I need him.

This Gomez was part of Madame Alexander's second go at the Addams Family:

Morticia on the Cissette body of the time demonstrates the female counterpart to this male body. Her face looks far more infantile than the male head.

I think Gomez is the only good doll in this set. Morticia and Wednesday have no business wearing purple and Pugsley isn't interesting. The prior adaptation of the family is better all around, with that set's Gomez having a more typical Madame face sculpt.

And V1 Morticia is how it's done!

The V1 Addams dolls might be loosely inspired by the Barry Sonnenfeld duology in the 1990s. Gomez's smoking jacket, Pugsley's hairstyle, and Tish's red lip are evocative of those movies, but Wednesday isn't dressed like the Christina Ricci version and Gomez's face and build look more like the original Charles Addams cartoons than Raúl Juliá. Madame Alexander's second Gomez looks more like his pre-Wednesday live actors, all of whom were more tall and slender than the original cartoon design.

I like both Gomez dolls, but swapping the fathers to put v2 Gomez with the v1 family might create the perfect set for me. I'm sure the V1 family has lower articulation, though. And I'm perfectly happy getting v2 Gomez solo, seeing as I have a Monster High Morticia also uncoupled (because she never got her man).  I am curious how the male body of v1 Gomez compares to the v2. I assume v1 Pugsley is only padded by his costume, and isn't on a fatter body.

All this is to say that I'd be interested in looking at the V1 Addams set plus V2 Gomez sometime, though I don't know if they should be next Halloween's features or come sooner!

EDIT: Turns out the v2 Addams set are based on the Broadway show and the color choices I objected to weren't Madame's own. The second set being based on a specific portrayal of the family lends credence to the first set being based on the Sonnenfeld movies, though.

Interestingly, both Gomez and Oscar have sculpted hair, and...wait a minute.



They really wigged over that thing, huh? That solves it then--there was only one head mold, used by all three men! Gomez and Oscar have different hairlines, but the sculpt must be the same underneath the paint, and Mercury uses the same mold and tries to hide it. I have no idea how I didn't notice that before. Now it feels glaring. I wish they had sprung for a new bald mold or like, sanded the cast head first? Awkward. I wonder if the hat would fit without the wig, too.

My attempt to sand the forehead in response was flawed, leaving some scratch scars and uneven surface, but it reduced the visibility of the hairline molding and improved the look overall. I think I have a clear and obvious winner for the production-value consideration in my Hatter Madness pool, though, and it's not Mercury. 

I don't want to sound condescending or dismissive, but there's something very endearing about the angsty, self-interested tragic vibe this doll gives off. Like, his feelings are real, but it's entertaining the way he chooses to indulge them. The  doll himself isn't quite as weepy and moody as I envisioned he would be, but I still indulged the tone a little.





For ages, I was certain this Hatter's Tenniel photoshoot would be the loneliest in the series, with no Hare or Dormouse or Alice to pair with him. I thought about attempting to craft pseudo-mechanical steampunk figurines in their places as if Mercury has built his own party companions...and then I realized I could just pop in premade steampunk-robot girl Robecca with a restyle to be the guest Alice! I picked her G3 version, whose gentle face and frills suit Alice better. As I shared in the review then, I also ended up with a spare swap-out head for her, which I could now restyle into a more Alice-like appearance. I boiled the hair straight and tied a simple ribbon headband on to sweep the hair back, and redressed Robecca with other pieces to look more dainty.


She's taller than Mercury, but that's okay.


I put together a steampunk tea table with a photo frame that could be used for both clock and gear imagery, with the glass of the frame laid loose over the top here above the clock features. A glass-top oval table is new for the array I've built! I had the same frustrations trying to stick on legs and a tabletop arm add-on that I encountered with Madeline's table. I don't know why I keep doing this to myself!




This was the wobbliest of the three "quirky tables" I built for this review series, but it's also the only one that didn't break "on set". I think it helped that this time, I was able to get the side table arm affixed with a screw.

My shooting echoed the experience I had with Attractionistas Maddie, where I did the shot on multiple "sets" because my first idea didn't nail it. I tried to have the scene outside with an emphasis on autumn, but the scene wasn't warm enough. I suppose the cold part of autumn being in full swing didn't help. I'm expecting healthy snow this winter.




Unlike Disney Maddie, Mercury found his shot in location 2 and didn't need a third restaging. I moved the autumn out and took the scene down to the boiler. 


This still doesn't look like much, but the shoot was unlocked with the lighting. I grabbed a dollhouse light from my Mini Sadie's home and put it on the tabletop. That made all the difference--in many ways, it's a gaslit teatime! 


Okay, well, that's a little too Rembrandt in its starkness, so leaving the opposite half of the basement illuminated added enough to make a good portrait suiting a moody steampunk tone that highlighted the scenery.





Here's the final Tenniel shot:


And like with Disney Maddie's winning staging, I did a zoomed-out view too.


Here's a few more portraits.




Here's all of the Hatters at the table now.


Mercury is an interesting doll. He's an unusual format for Madame Alexander, and he has a lot going for him visually. He feels vintage and antique with his simplistic face sculpt and fancy clothes. I love his color palette and the way his clothes are constructed is very nice. I also enjoy his articulation and his overall time-capsule of a contemporary aesthetic. He's more ambitious than successful, though. I can't comprehend how his hat was ever envisioned to work since it's outright not sewn for his dome. A larger piece would be better. I'm also not impressed by them slapping a wig over a head mold with sculpted hair, and not considering how the sculpt would peek out at the hairline. The sleepy eyes are also a bit disappointing. Were they stiff and adjustable, that would be nice, but my shrinking confidence any Madame dolls were intentionally designed that way means that was never likely. I also didn't think the clothes felt ideally tailored, with the jacket fitting awkwardly and the tails not sitting elegantly. I do like the boots, and waistcoat, though. The articulation is alright and is the bar to clear as far as Madame Alexander dolls I've experienced, but it's not as good as most modern fashion dolls and the hip joints having a diagonal swivel is baffling given that the body design should easily allow a natural lateral swing. Mercury is definitely a valuable curiosity to have explored. He's a doll with a niche all his own and brought out some autumn vibes in the post-Halloween time of year that usually doesn't enthrall me. Maybe in a different pool of dolls, he'd be a superstar. He just has stiff competition. I do think I will be getting the Gomez on his build, and maybe the other set of Addams dolls too. That could be fun.


Hatter Madness's final pre-conclusion installment will be its last interlude of unofficial non-contenders I wanted to discuss. For a while, I thought they'd publish first, but I ended up able to publish Mercury first, so that's how it's going to go. The official pool of contenders is now finished, though! See you in the last two parts soon.

2 comments:

  1. That second set of Addams Family dolls were designed to tie into the Broadway musical. This is why the outfits do have more colour to them - they're replicating the stage outfits.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I see. I disagree with the theatrical costume choice, then!

      Delete