Saturday, November 21, 2026

Hatter Madness Finale


I can't believe this isn't my last big-idea series of the year, but this is definitely the most conceptual, and now it's time to wrap it up!

I started Hatter Madness when I realized there were multiple Mad Hatter dolls I was intrigued by. Learning of the Silver Label doll at the end of last year galvanized me because I had to investigate that one, and this became the spot where I reviewed Ever After High Maddie and LDD's Sybil Hatter, dolls that were always going to end up somewhere on this blog. This project was a mix of the familiar and unfamiliar, through discovering dolls I was never aware of and acquiring dolls I wanted for a while. None of these are dolls I've owned before, though. Maddie was one of two Ever After High Wonderlandians who never made it to my teenage collection in any form, let alone her signature doll. All of these faces were new to me.


Note: Attractionistas Maddie is wearing Ever After High Bunny Blanc's boots.

As I did in Attractionistas Maddie's review, I'm referring to Ever After High's character in full as "Madeline" in this post for clarity's sake.

Despite none of the Hatters being on a template shared with each other, things balanced out okay. From the group I curated, half of the selection is male and half is female (even though Sybil's version of the Hatter is arguably gender-ambiguous, the Sybil character in the role of the Hatter is female). Half can contribute to a communal tea table with tea-serving accessories (Silver Label, Ever After High, technically LDD thanks to Series 23's later release) while half of my choices definitively have no doll-scale teaware (Storyland, Attractionistas, Steam Punk). Disney Maddie has an accessory in the form of her pet, but it's not tea serving.

Everybody's accessories at their feet. Sybil needs an arm swap to use the LDD teapot, which is not technically hers.

Aesthetically, the dolls are disparate. I'd say the most similar dolls are obviously the two Maddies, as Attractionistas, reads, intentionally or not, like a transparent cash-in on Ever After High. Suspicion and discourse surrounded Disney Maddie thanks to her similarities, though the actual circumstances might make it very plausible, if not the most likely reality, that the two are coincidental. The Silver Label Hatter plays in the same aesthetic as the Maddies do, too, and fits best with his fellow Mattel design, Madeline.


The steampunk Hatter and Sybil have some similarities, though Sybil is more seriously, and likely, more authentically, alternative. 


All of these official Hatters are White or coded as such, and while a Victorian English milliner most likely would be, I'd be open to official doll designs depicting the archetype through Black characters, and pursued an unofficial interpretive design with a Black doll myself.


Of the group of Hatters, four definitively have a matching Alice figure within their doll lines--the Madame Alexander Storyland doll, the Silver Label Hatter, Madeline Hatter (whose Alice is Alistair Wonderland), and Sybil. I custom-built a hybrid doll to pair with the Silver Label doll to be his Alice in lieu of his official partner, and I turned G3 Robecca into the Alice for steampunk Mercury, who has no official scene partners. Of the officially-paired Alices, I declined to get those intended for Storyland or Silver Label, and Storyland's shoot ended up as the only one with no Alice whatsoever.  Attractionistas Maddie is debatable in this consideration, because while there's no Alice role in the Attractionistas doll format, Maddie's design concept of being based on a ride based on the animated Disney Alice film means that any doll of animated Disney Alice is a matching Alice for Maddie, and using a Disney Alice doll is just what I did.

Regarding the other party attendants, I had to improvise. Only the Storyland doll has a compatible Dormouse (in the same Wendy doll style, but not the same series the Storyland doll was released in), while none of these dolls' collections or brands at large have made a March Hare. I improvised across the shoots, constructing Dormice and March Hares for my first two shoots, while bringing a Dormouse companion back for Sybil. Arguably, Maddie's white rabbit pet stood in for the March Hare despite it being based clearly on the White Rabbit. Madeline and the steampunk Hatter got no such companions from me at all--only guest Alices. 

As for who feels like the most accurate adaptation of the immortal John Tenniel artwork?


All of these dolls take interpretive leaps removing them from Tenniel's art. Actually, the Effanbee Hatter, who is not in contention, has the most on-model translation of the Tenniel  Hatter costume out of any doll I've seen. 


That's basically spot-on to Tenniel as far as visual design, but the default head is nothing like the art. 

Ultimately, Silver Label is the official contending pick who best evokes Tenniel in my mind.


Nearly every detail has been changed. He doesn't even have the label on his hat; that's a vital detail! He's also so gentle and old, looking like a quiet friendly granddad. And yet, Sharon Zuckerman's design beautifully captures the surreal quality, odd proportions, and Victorian whimsy which are so strongly associated with the story and Tenniel's art. I see the book character as I've always known him when I look at the doll despite acknowledging every difference. 

Mercury might barely count as the second-most accurate despite his youthful look, emo makeup, and steampunk theme, as he is, on paper, a Victorian gentleman with the famous hat label who also leverages the steampunk aesthetic for some book-relevant clock imagery.


Sybil is the next step further off-tone and her costume departs further from the bones of the Tenniel art, but it still feels like a thoughtful adaptation. The hat has the label, the fashion core is Victorian, and the black feathers work as a clever reference to the Hatter's famous unsolved raven riddle.


Of the male Hatters, Storyland is technically the least accurate, due to none of his details or aesthetic mapping precisely to Tenniel or Victorian authenticity, but I do love him. Madeline and Maddie are feminized Hatters with more whimsy than Tenniel, but without the similarities held by Silver Label. Madeline is technically more authentic in her flavor than Maddie, as Maddie feels more influenced by the modernist 1950s design that flavored the Disney adaptation she's derived from.

As with my LDD Series 23 project, I staged each doll's review photos in a different human-scale "tea table" tableau, each shot in a different location in my house. I didn't put quite as much intensive thought into thematic tea servings, and focused more on iconography and colors that suited the dolls. Here are those scenes staged for cover photos:

Hatter Madness 1 cover photo.

Another shot from the photoshoot to display the food I served here.

Hatter Madness 2 cover photo.

Hatter Madness 3 cover photo.

Hatter Madness 4 cover photo.

Hatter Madness 5 cover photo.

Hatter Madness 6 cover photo.

My favorite tea and favorite cover photo might be Madeline's. The colors came out great and I'm extremely biased by giving her my favorite cookies on her set...though I also really liked the treats I put together for Maddie. I also adore the cover composition of Silver Label with the doll in a teacup.

The other recurring shoot was imitating the composition of John Tenniel's illustration of the tea party:


Some of the dolls had much looser adherence to the original art by virtue of not having all of the cast to match each Hatter or deliberately going more interpretive, but my closest two, in descending order, were the Silver Label and LDD shots.

Storyland's shot, aiming to capture a cozy artificial toylike environment as might be used for a toy catalogue or vintage stop-motion series.

Silver Label's shot, aiming for the most accurate re-creation possible--and doing very well.

Madeline's shot, with a much wackier table and scene befitting the EAH version of Wonderland. Restyled Al guests.

Maddie's photo, capturing a funhouse tone of fifties modernist surrealism that lingers as the artistic impression of the film. Alice is sitting in a Disney teacup of teacups.

Sybil's shot--another very close re-creation, but with everything spookified per LDD; shot outdoors at night.

Steampunk shot--lighting did everything here, while the industrial scenery fit the tone. G3 Robecca plays Alice.

Disney Maddie and the steampunk Hatter needed a couple of migrations and restagings to get their shots right, but I'm ultimately happy with every one of these. Each captures a different aesthetic and extracts the tone and worlds I'd place these dolls within. My favorite thing to do with photos is to flesh out the visual identity of the toy into the scenery they'd inhabit, and it was a really fun exercise to re-adapt the same composition to each of these dolls and their aesthetics, straying and adhering based on the way I read each doll. The most accurate Tenniel photoshoot, was unsurprisingly, the one starring the most accurate doll: Silver Label.

Ultimately, the question of who would be Top Hatter stopped being a remotely fair two reviews in. You probably saw this coming.


The Silver Label doll was the champion from the moment I unboxed him. Honestly, this contest might have been won from the second I became aware of him; he was the reason I did this whole project! His visual design is enchanting and impressive. His clothing looks fantastic and is perfectly tailored and nicely made. His articulation is needlessly strong. He delivered zero frustrations and complete enthrallment. He conveys Tenniel's art the best even through his own artistic liberties. The Silver Label Hatter instantly became one of my favorite doll acquisitions of the entire year...and I'm now completely comfortable saying he's actually my very favorite doll of the entire year. 

Well done!

I'm calling it slightly early, but I don't think this judgment can change before January! (Some possible competition is being saved as Christmas gifts to self, and reviews with which to begin 2027.) Since posting the Silver Label review, I've come back to reread it more than anything else I've written this year, and my experience with him has been one of the most delightful, pleasant, and positively surprising in my 2026 explorations. I've never even singled out a "favorite doll of the year" before, but this guy...he's the only answer if I was asked about 2026. He's gonna center the end-of-year reflection tableau.

Possibly the closest yet furthest, as far as challenging the Silver Label doll for the top spot, would have been the steampunk doll. He has nearly comparable articulation and detail...but he stumbles in so many places where the Silver Label doll excels, so he can't be considered equal, let alone superior. The fascination I have with Silver Label just isn't there for the steampunk doll. I think my actual second favorite might be split between the two dolls with spirals--Storyland and Sybil. 


Storyland's aesthetic is so charming and cozy and retro and sweet, but he's a little fiddly to pose and his shoes stick to surfaces he stands on. Sybil is a killer aesthetic, but is improved by accessories and an arm that can hold the teapot she doesn't include, and her context is quite aesthetically different from the classic Carroll, and she fits only a specific mood. I also didn't like the way her eyepatch was put on officially. I like Ever After High Maddie and Mercury (the steampunk doll) quite a lot, and I'm not sure who I'd say I prefer. Maybe EAH. Attractionistas Maddie has to be the lowest because her production value felt poor even for a cheap type of collector doll. She had bad hair, disappointing articulation, ugly cutoff leggings, ill-fit shoes, and a hat far too heavy to wear as intended.

Here's all of the custom dolls I ended up making during this project--two Alices (the Polly Pocket is really just a messy throwaway) and three Hatters.


Alice in the yellow dress and my modernist SnapStar Hatter are my favorites of this group. Alice conveys the character in just the same manner as the Silver Label Hatter I designed her for--nothing one-to-one, but spiritually all there. Her hybrid doll build isn't totally successful. Her arms feel too short and her neck rigging isn't attractive, but she works well enough and is often surreal in the right way. If Alice didn't have those awkward factors remaining from how her doll parts were forced together, she'd be just as perfect as Silver Label Hatter.


I got another pair of forearms in this faux-BJD doll style from another doll kit, but I don't think they'd be compatible with this doll's joints.

The SnapStar Hatter is more functional in terms of hybrid build, only having foreign hands popped in which fit well, and she's a really fun character design. The Ken-headed Hatter on the white mini BJD body was a good experiment, but I don't want to keep him. The body, which is really nice, might go onto better things. The Polly and Effanbee efforts also didn't enthrall me.

I bought two non-Hatter dolls for the purposes of this project which I kept basically as-is rather than turning them into custom fodder: the Effanbee Queen of Hearts and the most recent playline Disney Store Alice (the latter being part of Maddie's post).


The Effanbee Queen is remarkable for her caricatured distorted grotesque face and her costume design having elements that combine to make her the most spiritually accurate to John Tenniel's art of the Queen of Hearts dolls I've seen. She's amusing and a fun novelty, but the doll build is limited in its posing and display potential and she's not the most impressively-produced. Disney Alice isn't a spectacular doll, either, but she by far has my favorite doll packaging I might have ever encountered, using zero plastic to secure her within her genuinely gorgeous cardboard box. That must be celebrated. I want Alice's packaging standards for everyone.


Who did I leave out? Well, I've touched on this a bit-- none of the various dolls of the Tim Burton Hatter, though I'm game to get them back. I loved the brown-suited Jakks doll, and putting his clothes on the better likeness of the blue-jacket Barbie collector piece could create the perfect doll. 

This doll was cheap cheap cheap but had an enchanting antique quality to his coat and his watercolor-like face paint. He looked nothing like the film character facially, though, and the hair was atrocious.

Barbie licenses are so deadly when they put in the effort. This has to be the best doll translation, but I've never experienced this one.

I would not re-pursue the Disney Store Through the Looking Glass Hatter.


The facial likeness was strong, but I'd have much preferred a grin to this stoic intensity, and I like his film-1 hairstyle and color more than this past-era design. I also hated the male Disney Store body he was on, preferring the Jakks body, and wasn't a fan of the costume.

I didn't pick the Liv brand's "Katie as the Hatter" doll either, as mentioned.


I could have picked Katie and balanced the genders out again by also adding in Max Hatter from the new Descendants: Wicked Wonderland collection, but he's in a two-pack and looks low-quality, and like Katie, the design just wasn't interesting enough. He also fails the "doll-original character design" criterion. While it's arguable the movie was created to sell dolls, he is still best described as a doll adaptation of a simultaneous movie character.


The Hatters I chose all had visual aesthetics I could build scenery around, stylized precisely in tune with the designs of the dolls. Katie and Max don't give me nearly as strong of a photo vibe to latch onto.

One last thing--updates on Madeline's curls and the reshaping of the gripping arm I gave Sybil. The curls have loosened but not gone lank and ruined, while the gripping arm seemed to reshape properly and it's capable of holding onto the LDD teapot as I wanted.

Phew. That does it for Hatter Madness! It's a little sad, but a little bit of a relief, to finally put away the tableau that's taken up space in my room since March. I'm not sure what the future of every doll will be regarding my collection, but I know for sure the Silver Label doll and Sybil won't be expecting to leave anytime soon. I might get more Hatters through the Tim Burton character but I probably won't revive this series format or call it an epilogue if I do. As mentioned, I could try spotlighting Queen of Hearts dolls, but having gotten started with a few different such dolls already reviewed, it might not make much sense or be worth it to try doing a series from it. It was really cool to spotlight a single Alice character and adaptations exclusive to toys, and the Queen has a comparable, if not greater, repertoire. I could see myself ditching the "no licenses" idea and discussing the Silver Label Queen, the Liv doll adaptation, the Descendants 4 Rita Ora Queen, and a couple of Disney's self-adaptations of the 1959 design...but I already talked about Lizzie Hearts, LDD Inferno's stint, and the Effanbee doll! What would I do to reconcile those posts? Hm. I might not even go there, at least not anytime soon. For now, it's off to crank out the Haunted Mansion series and think about some festive celebrations and a stockpile of special holiday acquisitions with which to start off the new year.

No comments:

Post a Comment